Oct. 15, 2023
CC#26--The 2023 Synod Has A History
FAN MAIL--We would love YOUR feedback--Send us a Text Message Prepare to be taken on a captivating journey through tumultuous times within the Catholic Church. We're dissecting the monumental Synod of Synodality, currently in session in Rome. Inspired by Pope Francis’ vision for a more unified Church, this Synod is tackling critical issues such as authority within the Church, the role of the laity in decision-making, Episcopal Collegiality, and unofficially the hot-button topics like ...
FAN MAIL--We would love YOUR feedback--Send us a Text Message
Prepare to be taken on a captivating journey through tumultuous times within the Catholic Church. We're dissecting the monumental Synod of Synodality, currently in session in Rome.
Inspired by Pope Francis’ vision for a more unified Church, this Synod is tackling critical issues such as authority within the Church, the role of the laity in decision-making, Episcopal Collegiality, and unofficially the hot-button topics like blessing same-sex marriages and ordination of women priests.
As we navigate these waters, we draw insights from Edward Pentin's revealing book, "Rigging of a Vatican Synod," an exposé on the alleged manipulations at the extraordinary 2014 synod on the family.
Key Points from the Episode:
- We're taking a deep dive into the controversies and allegations surrounding the 2014 Synod of Bishops.
- Supposed manipulations, disproportionate support for those favoring a change in the Church's stance on homosexuality, and a controversial interim report are just some of the issues we are discussing.
- What was Pope Francis' role in this? How did the desire for an open and free debate end up side-lined?
- With insights from Ed Pentin's book, we untangle the complex web of the Synod's controversies and examine how they impacted the traditional doctrine of the Church.
- Finally, we're reflecting on the past, and looking towards the future of the Catholic Church.
- We discuss the warnings against 'innovative pastoral practices' disguised as false doctrine, Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI's response to the controversial 2014 Synod, and the potential for the current Synod of Synodality to reshape the Church according to Pope Francis’ vision.
Join us on this quest to understand the complexities, controversies, and potential changes within the Catholic Church. You don't want to miss this episode!
Other resources:
Ed Pentin's final chapter of his book, Rigging of a Vatican Synod (2015)
Cardinal Zen's pre-Synod full text letter to the attendees of the 2023 Synod on Synodality
More goodness
Get your FREE Academy Review here!
Get our top book recommendations list
Get new podcast episodes dropped into your email box easily
Want to leave a review? Click here, and if we earned a five-star review from you **high five and knuckle bumps**, we appreciate it greatly, thank you so much!
00:01 - The Synod of Synonality
06:44 - Manipulation Allegations in 2014 Synod
21:55 - Bishop Synod Challenges and Controversies
33:06 - Podcast Highlights & Resources
WEBVTT
00:00:01.665 --> 00:00:09.425
After two weeks of meetings in Rome at the Synod, do we know where these meetings are going, where they are directed?
00:00:09.425 --> 00:00:17.804
Or perhaps is the final document already written before this Synod ever started?
00:00:17.804 --> 00:00:22.222
Let's talk about this on the next Catholic Corner.
00:00:51.201 --> 00:01:04.406
Welcome to the Theory to Action Podcast, where we examine the timeless treasures of wisdom from the great books in less time, to help you take action immediately and ultimately to create and lead a flourishing life.
00:01:04.406 --> 00:01:08.447
Now here's your host, David Kaiser.
00:01:11.500 --> 00:01:22.692
Hello, I am David and welcome back to another Catholic Corner and to another enlightening episode of our podcast, where we delve into the profound happenings within the Catholic Church.
00:01:22.692 --> 00:01:30.373
Today, we're going to turn our focus to the monumental Synod of Synonality.
00:01:30.373 --> 00:01:40.487
It's a tongue twister, but it's taking place, has been taking place for the last two weeks in the heartbeat of Catholicism in Rome, italy.
00:01:40.487 --> 00:01:54.070
This gathering, inspired by Pope Francis' vision, is a pivotal stepping stone on the Church's path towards what he professes to be greater unity.
00:01:54.070 --> 00:02:15.693
We will be exploring the discussions that hundreds, perhaps thousands, of attendees to the Synod are engaging in right now, and these official issues that they're discussing are the authority within the Church, the role of laity in the decision making and the Episcopal Collegiality.
00:02:15.693 --> 00:02:30.354
Now it's worth mentioning a topic that has been the subject of much speculation and debate within Catholic Corners and Catholic Circles, rather, the issue of the blessing of same-sex marriages.
00:02:30.354 --> 00:02:38.463
While it's not explicitly on this official Synod agenda, it's hard to ignore its silent prominence.
00:02:38.463 --> 00:02:43.889
It's a matter that is stirring up conversations, despite not being formally addressed.
00:02:43.889 --> 00:03:01.549
This contentious issue embodies the diverse discussions happening at the Synod, indicative of a Church grappling with modernity while rooted in tradition and Scripture, now adding to the list of the contemporary issues being explored is.
00:03:01.549 --> 00:03:07.609
Another area Taking attention is the ordination of women priests in the Catholic Churches.
00:03:07.609 --> 00:03:18.043
This topic resurfaces time and time again in the life of the Church, so we will explore that topic as well Now.
00:03:18.082 --> 00:03:31.913
Indeed, there are some who are making audacious predictions that this Synod may herald a seismic shift akin to what the Church experienced in the 16th century with the Protestant Revolt.
00:03:31.913 --> 00:03:35.568
A bold claim, certainly, but not without merit.
00:03:35.568 --> 00:03:46.912
The winds of change are indeed blowing, and the Church stands at a precipice of decisions that could reshape its future and redefine its relationship with the modern world.
00:03:46.912 --> 00:03:57.270
So as we travel through these captivating times together in faith and fellowship, one cannot help but feel the echoes of the past reverberating through the present.
00:03:57.270 --> 00:04:02.715
They offer us both cautionary tales and hopeful promises.
00:04:02.715 --> 00:04:07.368
Are we on the cusp of a seismic shift within the Catholic Church?
00:04:07.368 --> 00:04:12.911
Only time will tell, but join us as we continue to follow these fascinating developments.
00:04:14.280 --> 00:04:26.029
Now, my friends, we're going to turn to our book of the day and to the author whose name is synonymous with incisive Vatican reporting.
00:04:26.029 --> 00:04:28.779
His name is Edward Penton.
00:04:28.779 --> 00:04:36.194
Now Ed Penton is the esteemed senior Vatican reporter for the National Catholic Register.
00:04:36.194 --> 00:04:44.586
He has steadfastly dedicated his career to uncovering and sharing the truth of the Holy Sea with the world.
00:04:44.586 --> 00:04:49.581
He has wonderful insights and a deep understanding of the inner workings of the Vatican.
00:04:49.581 --> 00:05:00.048
He's renowned for his journalistic integrity and investigative acumen, and Penton brings an objective lens to his reporter.
00:05:00.048 --> 00:05:07.132
He is a Catholic, but he also fosters a sense of trust and credibility among his readers and listeners across the globe.
00:05:07.814 --> 00:05:29.687
Now, as we explore the complexities of this synod, there is no one better equipped to guide us, and the reason I chose this book is because back in 2014, right after Pope Francis was elected, there was the 2014 extraordinary synod on the family, and Edward Penton wrote a book about it.
00:05:29.687 --> 00:05:34.380
Let's delve into this remarkable piece of work.
00:05:34.380 --> 00:05:47.430
The title, which is the rigging of a Vatican synod an investigation into the alleged manipulation at the extraordinary synod of the family.
00:05:47.430 --> 00:05:57.954
This book is an illuminating expose of the 2014 extraordinary synod on the family, and here's a brief overview of the book.
00:05:57.954 --> 00:06:05.901
Following the newly elected Pope Francis, the synod was a pivotal moment in the modern church history.
00:06:05.901 --> 00:06:12.596
Edward Penton, with his sharp journalistic lens, leaves no stone unturned.
00:06:12.596 --> 00:06:21.723
He offers readers an unprecedented behind the scenes look at this synod and he unravels the complexities of the event with remarkable clarity.
00:06:21.723 --> 00:06:32.307
This book discusses the alleged manipulations and the politicking that supposedly swayed the synod's outcome.
00:06:32.307 --> 00:06:42.194
This is a must read for those seeking an in-depth understanding of the machinations within the Vatican during this critical period of time.
00:06:44.420 --> 00:06:49.987
So if you're like me and you read that, you're probably thinking, huh, I didn't know about this synod.
00:06:49.987 --> 00:06:54.137
What's this quote rigging of the synod all about?
00:06:54.137 --> 00:06:55.839
I got some questions here.
00:06:55.839 --> 00:07:08.550
Some of my questions are what are the key manipulations that Edward Penton is allegedly occurred during this 2014 synod of the family?
00:07:08.550 --> 00:07:13.865
And how does Edward Penton describe the role of Pope Francis in this synod?
00:07:13.865 --> 00:07:18.901
And why, according to Penton, was the synod a pivotal moment in modern church history?
00:07:18.901 --> 00:07:30.591
So in my research and digging through the book, there is a lot, so much that I can't in any way do justice for the whole book.
00:07:30.591 --> 00:07:31.865
But here is the good news.
00:07:31.865 --> 00:07:34.725
I'll provide a link to the book if you want to get it on Kindle.
00:07:34.725 --> 00:07:48.540
But more importantly, ed Penton, the author, just last month included a significant part of his last chapter of the book for free on his website.
00:07:48.540 --> 00:07:55.000
I'll put a link in the show notes to that, but let me grab some significant quotes from this last chapter.
00:07:56.103 --> 00:08:01.798
Going to the book the stated purpose of a third extraordinary assembly.
00:08:01.798 --> 00:08:18.122
The synod of bishops was straightforward but risky To open up a debate on some of the most neuralistic issues facing the church and her teaching, issues that have wrought the tension and division for some past 50 years.
00:08:18.122 --> 00:08:28.468
The apparent hope was that it would enable her to offer a more unified and effective pastoral response to the challenges facing the family today.
00:08:28.468 --> 00:08:32.081
To many it seemed to further that goal.
00:08:32.081 --> 00:08:40.828
They saw the synod as salutary, collegial and an inspirational experience that showed the great universality of the church.
00:08:40.828 --> 00:08:53.009
They welcomed the way in which, for the first time, it gave those who hold different views, or what Cardinal Bram, euler and others would criticize as heretical perspectives, a full earring.
00:08:54.312 --> 00:08:59.866
Now, many of those who saw the meeting so positively tended to reject the allegations of manipulation.
00:08:59.866 --> 00:09:08.027
Even some of them were critical of certain procedures or decisions of the synodal leaders.
00:09:08.027 --> 00:09:24.711
Some who rejected the progressive positions pushed by some of the meeting's heads and espoused by some synod fathers also thought the final outcome of the synod was positive, despite certain missteps.
00:09:24.711 --> 00:09:28.418
So that's interesting.
00:09:28.418 --> 00:09:38.642
So many of those who the meeting so positively tended, they ended up rejecting the allegations of the manipulation.
00:09:38.642 --> 00:09:40.044
So that's fair.
00:09:40.044 --> 00:09:42.089
But let's keep going.
00:09:42.089 --> 00:09:48.163
But whatever one makes of the charges of manipulation.
00:09:48.403 --> 00:10:09.020
This book shows that Pope Francis's wish for an open and free debate in which all parties could listen with humility was seriously impeded, whether by dubious procedures inadequate to the tasks at hand, as some claim, or by outright manipulation by the leaders with an agenda, as others claim.
00:10:10.203 --> 00:10:30.941
At the very least, it seems that the Casper position, that would be Cardinal Casper, and that of those favoring a change regarding homosexuality, received support from the synod leadership significantly disproportionate to the real support for those positions among the synod fathers.
00:10:32.063 --> 00:10:43.504
Add to this the publicly created by the media release of the interim report and the result was a highly controversial synod.
00:10:44.524 --> 00:10:57.556
One side targeted for repression was, bizarrely, the one that upheld the Catholic traditional doctrine of the church, passed down from one generation to the next for some 2000 years.
00:10:57.556 --> 00:11:03.136
This led the Synod to become, in the words of one cardinal, grossly unfair.
00:11:03.136 --> 00:11:18.634
The principle to hear the arguments of both sides was aggressively disregarded, despite the fact that it is one of the two norms of natural justice, both in canon law and in civil law.
00:11:18.634 --> 00:11:36.804
Suddenly, merely restating the church's long held doctrine on key issues left one open to bowling and intimidation and threats, not so much by the media as by some of Get this in senior church positions, even those in charge of the Synod itself.
00:11:36.804 --> 00:11:53.618
This book has, one hopes, gone some way in presenting the extent of the problems within the process of the extraordinary Synod of 2014 and has identified those who were the principal protagonist of the difficulties.
00:11:53.618 --> 00:12:02.802
Ah, so one side was targeted for repression and that was the side that upheld the traditional doctrine the church.
00:12:02.802 --> 00:12:03.284
Hmm.
00:12:05.149 --> 00:12:26.831
Now the interesting thing about all this is in Ed's book, he highlights 13 different examples of where manipulations happened in the course of the 2014 Synod, and my reaction to 13 different examples was Holy smokes, holy smokes.
00:12:26.831 --> 00:12:30.363
Yes, 13 different examples.
00:12:30.363 --> 00:12:36.034
I I Originally thought there would be one or two or three and I thought what?
00:12:36.034 --> 00:12:38.038
This can be part of a miscommunication.
00:12:38.038 --> 00:12:42.854
This can be just, you know, different people seeing different sides of a certain issue.
00:12:42.854 --> 00:12:57.664
But 13 different examples is Almost an overwhelming number and as you read through each of these examples in the book, there's a lot of meat on the bone to each of these, as they say.
00:12:57.664 --> 00:13:05.136
And actually let's dig into just one example, because some of these examples are.
00:13:05.136 --> 00:13:15.615
They take anywhere from, you know, 15 to 20 to 25, 30 different pages to try and explain and pull apart and deduce.
00:13:15.615 --> 00:13:29.711
But on page 171 of this book, we have a chronology here and I think this is one significant example of the 13 dated October 13, 2014.
00:13:30.293 --> 00:13:33.566
The Synod fathers are presented with the Relatio.
00:13:33.566 --> 00:13:44.073
That's an interim report summarizing the discussions of just the first week, and it's purported to represent their views at a press briefing that afternoon.
00:13:44.073 --> 00:13:50.144
Cardinal Airdo and Archbishop Bruno Forte, the special secretary, are present.
00:13:50.144 --> 00:14:09.976
The Relatio is presented to the media as if it's the views of the Synod fathers, but significant patch passages, namely proposals to look at positive aspects of homosexual unions and cohabitations, were hardly or not at all discussed by the Synod fathers.
00:14:09.976 --> 00:14:24.351
Father Lombardi Says he recalls only one speech of about out of roughly 265 About homosexuals during the debate.
00:14:24.351 --> 00:14:37.691
When asked about the meaning of the passages relating to homosexuality, cardinal Airdo effectively disowns the document, pointing at Forte and saying he who wrote the text must know what he is talking about.
00:14:37.691 --> 00:14:50.697
It seems generally accepted that the document has largely Was largely written by Cardinal Forte, a disciple of the late Carlo Cardinal Martini, the Archbishop of Milan.
00:14:50.697 --> 00:15:03.999
Now the Associated Press describes Forte as a Italian theologian known for pushing the pastoral envelope on dealing with people in irregular unions while staying true to Catholic doctrine.
00:15:03.999 --> 00:15:14.133
The Relatio is sent to the press before it is read to the Synod fathers and then it's immediately reported around the world as a revolution in the church.
00:15:14.553 --> 00:15:25.817
Many practicing Catholics view passages relating to homosexuality, cohabitation, contraception and reception of holy communion by divorced persons living in invalid civil unions as scandalous.
00:15:25.817 --> 00:15:39.912
The report is roundly criticized by many Synod fathers, including Timothy Cardinal Dolan of New York, who says quote a lot of bishops I would include myself feel that it needs Some major reworking.
00:15:39.912 --> 00:15:40.956
End of quote.
00:15:40.956 --> 00:15:57.764
Now the Relatio is also published in various languages within 48 hours, suggesting to critics it was written before the end, or perhaps even before the start, of the first week and the conclusion of the discussions.
00:15:57.764 --> 00:16:13.254
It's claimed in response that Forte and other members of the drafting committee drew upon all the Synod fathers written submissions submitted Prior to the meeting and that these were factored in, even If the bishops did not utter them.
00:16:13.254 --> 00:16:34.304
Then, in an interview with an Italian magazine published the same day, l Fuggilio, cardinal Burke says it seems that, quote something is not working well if the information is manipulated in a way so as to stress only One position instead of reporting faithfully on the various positions that were expressed.
00:16:34.304 --> 00:16:46.991
He goes on to say this worries me very much Because a consistent number of bishops do not accept the idea of a break With traditional church teaching, but few know this.
00:16:46.991 --> 00:16:52.965
He adds the pope, named Cardinal Casper to the Synod and has let the debate go along this track.
00:16:52.965 --> 00:16:54.234
I Am waiting.
00:16:54.234 --> 00:17:09.048
I am waiting I the Pope's pronouncement, which is able to be only in the continuity with the teaching given by the church through her whole history, a teaching that is never changed because it cannot change.
00:17:10.805 --> 00:17:19.635
The Polish bishops then expressed concern that Pope St John Paul II's teachings on the family are not getting sufficient attention at the Synod.
00:17:19.635 --> 00:17:32.916
He's not mentioned once in the interim report, though some of his writings are cited a few times, and they see the Synod in general as a rejection of John Paul's work on the family.
00:17:32.916 --> 00:17:47.912
Continuing to quote from the book, the next day, october 14, 2014, at a press briefing, cardinal Napierre tells reporters that the interim report puts the church in a position that is quote virtually irredeemable.
00:17:47.912 --> 00:17:57.653
He says the content of the relatio is not what we're saying at all, and at the press received the text before the Synod fathers did.
00:17:57.653 --> 00:18:03.266
George Weigel would later comment that the leak enabled the media template to be quickly set.
00:18:03.266 --> 00:18:05.773
In a concrete quote it's finally happened.
00:18:05.773 --> 00:18:07.127
The church is changing.
00:18:07.127 --> 00:18:20.586
The Holy See Press Office does not deny the accusations of manipulation, but stresses that the interim report is a quote working document and is part of the ongoing Synodal process.
00:18:20.586 --> 00:18:25.035
And then we fast forward to a lot of back and forth.
00:18:25.035 --> 00:18:28.213
We pass over that to October 18, 2014.
00:18:29.025 --> 00:18:44.171
The final document is presented to the Synod fathers, although paragraphs 52, 53 and 55 on same sex unions, cohabitation and communion for divorced and civilly remarried failed to achieve the two thirds majority vote.
00:18:44.171 --> 00:18:51.994
Majority of votes, consensus orders that they be published in the final document as well.
00:18:51.994 --> 00:19:07.632
This surprises many, who feel that any proposals that failed to reach the agreed consensus in this case of two thirds of the majority should not be included, in accordance with the most legislative procedures agreed upon.
00:19:07.632 --> 00:19:14.310
Father Lombardi tells reporters that although the paragraphs do not express consensus, they were not completely rejected.
00:19:14.310 --> 00:19:28.576
He says they cannot be considered an expression of synodal consensus, but they show these topics to be a work in progress and that we still have a ways to go.
00:19:28.576 --> 00:19:38.251
Others point out that the paragraph still passed with a majority of over 50% of the votes, so their continued inclusion is legitimate.
00:19:38.251 --> 00:19:51.116
Later on, cardinal Burke says in an interview that it was not possible to have any discussion on that text, but we voted paragraph by paragraph.
00:19:51.116 --> 00:19:57.210
He adds what's the point of voting paragraph by paragraph except to either accept a paragraph or have it removed?
00:19:57.210 --> 00:20:03.207
This is just one more disturbing aspect about the way in which the synod of bishops was conducted.
00:20:04.424 --> 00:20:15.174
Some observers noted deafening silence with regard to references to St John Paul II's teachings on the family in all previous synod documents.
00:20:15.174 --> 00:20:26.214
In an interview with the D Zeit, cardinal Marx continues to push the agenda, claiming Pope Francis is ready to move the church ahead in a radical direction.
00:20:26.214 --> 00:20:29.575
Quote the synod debates were just the starting point.
00:20:29.575 --> 00:20:34.076
Francis wants to get things moving, to push processes forward.
00:20:34.076 --> 00:20:36.090
The real work is about to begin.
00:20:36.545 --> 00:20:55.357
The fact that the two hot button issues communion for divorce to remarried Catholics and on a more positive, open approach to homosexuality were discussed at the October 5th through the 19th Synod of Bishops on the Family and failed to get two thirds of majority, should not be seen as a setback.
00:20:55.357 --> 00:21:05.532
Standing who comes to that conclusion has not had his eye on what has been going on in our church over the past one and a half years.
00:21:05.532 --> 00:21:06.635
End of quote.
00:21:06.635 --> 00:21:18.734
So, as you can see, in just one of these quotes and I didn't, this was the easiest one to be able to pick out paragraphs and be able to share it with you.
00:21:18.734 --> 00:21:25.656
There's 13 other examples and much deeper examples as you read through this book.
00:21:25.656 --> 00:21:43.538
So I don't want to say there's something nefarious, but boy, just one of these quotes is very alarming and the other 12 are overwhelmingly problematic.
00:21:43.538 --> 00:21:45.730
Let's pull one more quote.
00:21:45.730 --> 00:21:51.036
This is a conclusion from Edward Penton's book, where he has done great writing.
00:21:51.036 --> 00:21:53.067
Let's pull this one last quote.
00:21:55.085 --> 00:22:11.953
In October 2015, the 14th Ordinary General Assembly, the Synod of Bishops on the Family, will take place on the theme of the vocation and mission of the family and the church in the contemporary world, the second of the two synods on the family.
00:22:11.953 --> 00:22:30.015
There are indications that the next Synod may wind up in a situation similar to that of the previous one, and now the key leaders have an agenda to emphasize innovative pastoral practices that many others see as being at odds with the church's established doctrine.
00:22:30.015 --> 00:22:43.538
Now, withstanding Pope Francis's wishes for an open discussion yielding a well-grounded unity, the next Synod may result in even more confusion and more dissension.
00:22:43.538 --> 00:22:57.009
To prevent this, some are looking upon the next Synod as a summons to return to established teachings of the church, to revert to scripture and tradition, which were largely sidelined at the last Synod.
00:22:57.009 --> 00:23:13.457
Critics of the last year's meeting believed that, after years of poor catechesis, doctrine must be reasserted and proclaimed, ending the false dichotomy underlying the notion that upholding the church's teaching and practice somehow means being un-pastoral.
00:23:13.457 --> 00:23:27.547
Jesus, they point out, took a pity on the crowd, who were like quote sheep without a shepherd, not by affirming them in their worldly thinking and values, but by first teaching them many things.
00:23:27.547 --> 00:23:38.394
They also warned about the false doctrine cloaked under the seductive guise of, quote innovative pastoral practices.
00:23:38.394 --> 00:23:39.699
End of quote.
00:23:39.699 --> 00:23:46.480
This is not new, of course, and no shortage of scriptural passages warn against it.
00:23:48.390 --> 00:24:02.441
Now, in terms of Ed Patton doing absolutely wonderful reporting, when all of this was taking place, pope Benedict had just retired.
00:24:02.441 --> 00:24:20.713
He was now Pope Emeritus and Ed, through his reporting, he has a footnote in this book about he was Pope Benedict was asked at the end of this Synod, the 2014 Synod on the family, and here's what Ed reported at the time.
00:24:20.713 --> 00:24:41.462
Quote it is related on good authority, but unconfirmed, that a visitor asked Pope Emeritus Benedict the 16th, after the 2014 Synod, what he thought about the meeting, to which he allegedly replied Halton Z Zick, unbedinked in D Lea.
00:24:41.462 --> 00:24:53.799
Now, my German is not that good, despite six years, three in high school, three in college but that translation means adhere strictly to the doctrine.
00:24:53.799 --> 00:25:00.451
Adhere strictly to the doctrine and again you would.
00:25:01.933 --> 00:25:15.036
You will remember, which took the world's surprise, that Pope Benedict the 16th announced his resignation on February 13th, citing a lack of strength in mind and body due to his advanced age.
00:25:15.036 --> 00:25:17.796
Now that decision was unprecedented.
00:25:17.796 --> 00:25:20.255
When Pope Benedict resigned.
00:25:20.255 --> 00:25:30.049
He was the first Pope to resign in almost six centuries, not since Pope Gregory the 12th stepped down on 415.
00:25:30.049 --> 00:25:46.038
Now, benedict's announcement sparked both shock and speculation, with his tenure marked by significant achievements in trouble and controversies, but his departure paved the way for the election of the now Holy Father, pope Francis.
00:25:46.038 --> 00:26:03.881
So again we have it on good authority that Pope Emeritus Benedict the 16th, who's now passed on God rest his soul With the 2014 Synod said adhere strictly to the doctrine.
00:26:06.009 --> 00:26:18.559
And then Ed in his book, makes references to two scripture passages on Jesus' teaching when he confronts the crowds and he says they are like a sheep without a shepherd.
00:26:18.559 --> 00:26:34.297
You will remember in Mark 634, when Jesus landed and he saw the long throng, the large throng, he had compassion on them because they were like a sheep without a shepherd, and it began to teach them many things.
00:26:34.297 --> 00:26:50.335
Or that other reference from Romans 12 to don't be conformed to this world, but be transformed by the renewal of your mind that you may prove what is the will of God, what is good and acceptable and perfect.
00:26:50.335 --> 00:27:10.400
So those are just two passages that Ed includes in his book about the role of the Holy Father, because it's indeed it's an essential part of the Holy Father's role to instruct the ignorant, providing guidance to all the members of the church on religious and moral issues.
00:27:10.400 --> 00:27:23.362
Now the Pope is the spiritual shepherd of the Catholic community worldwide, is called to lead his flock towards a path of righteousness, repentance and truth.
00:27:23.362 --> 00:27:33.960
His teachings, rooted in the doctrines of the church, serve to illuminate the minds of those seeking answers to the truth and to dispel the clouds of ignorance and uncertainty.
00:27:33.960 --> 00:27:51.920
By adhering strictly to the teachings, the deposit of faith, individuals can gain a deeper understanding of the faith in its central tenets, enabling them to lead lives that are in harmony with the church's teaching and with the teachings of Christ.
00:27:53.930 --> 00:28:06.582
Now Ed, in the last part of his books, makes reference to this saying quote they also warn about false doctrine cloaked under the seductive guise of innovative pastoral practice.
00:28:06.582 --> 00:28:12.519
This is not new, of course, and no shortage of scriptural passages worn against it.
00:28:12.519 --> 00:28:26.433
And here Ed rightly cites two scriptures that seem to be talking to us about our current synod, from 2 Timothy 4-3,.
00:28:26.433 --> 00:28:30.541
For the time is coming when people will not endure sound teaching.
00:28:30.541 --> 00:28:51.993
Having itching ears, they will accumulate for themselves teachers to suit their own likings and will turn away from listening to the truth and wander into myths, and from Romans 1, 21, and 122, they will become futile in their thinking and their senseless minds were darkened.
00:28:51.993 --> 00:28:56.260
Claiming to be wise, they became fools.
00:28:56.260 --> 00:29:30.468
So we have the evidence from Ed Penton's wonderful reporting in his book that the 2014 Synod on the family appears to be severely manipulated, rigged, as Ed Penn has written and I would also point you to Cardinal Joseph Zen, the predominant Cardinal from Hong Kong, who wrote a letter just before the beginning of this Synod here in 2023?
00:29:32.361 --> 00:29:51.161
Saying I'm supposing that you are as worried as I am about the outcome of this Synod, so in this letter that I'll put a link in the show notes for you, he highlights many things, but he goes back and highlights how this 2014 Synod extraordinary Synod was rigged.
00:29:51.161 --> 00:29:52.964
Now, who's Cardinal Zen?
00:29:52.964 --> 00:29:54.188
Well, like I said, he's the.
00:29:54.188 --> 00:29:57.807
He's the prominent figure in the Catholic Church from Hong Kong.
00:29:57.807 --> 00:30:07.744
As Bishop for more than 26 years, he's dedicated his life to theological service and Orthodoxy and upholding the sacred tradition of the Catholic faith.
00:30:07.744 --> 00:30:26.684
He's now at the venerable age of 91, but he continues To be a holy warrior with an active voice, sharing his insights and concerns about the developments in the church, such as this Synod on Synonality.
00:30:26.684 --> 00:30:33.063
Like I said, I'll put a link in the show notes for this full text of his letter.
00:30:33.825 --> 00:30:45.444
So, in conclusion, we ourselves At the beginning of this episode, we ask questions Do we know where the synodal meetings are going and where they are to be directed?
00:30:45.444 --> 00:30:58.949
Or perhaps is this Final document from this synod already written before it is even over the first two questions, we have a better idea now.
00:30:58.949 --> 00:31:05.928
And To that third question most likely that answer is the document has already been written.
00:31:05.928 --> 00:31:17.701
It's sad to say that and to compliment contemplate that, but as past history is proving to be prologue, it sounds like that's the truth.
00:31:19.118 --> 00:31:51.126
So, as we find ourselves at a crossroad in time, navigating the complexities of faith and doctrine in a rapidly changing world, with a Rutterless church right now in Rome, and while innovation and progression are indeed fundamental to personal and societal evolution, it's crucial now More than ever that we cling to the unchanging truth of the gospel, to the truth of Christ given to us in the sacred, to positive faith.
00:31:51.126 --> 00:32:06.148
Without question, we must heed Pope Emeritus Benedict, the 16th wise counsel, adheres strictly to the doctrine, and remember the scriptural warnings against false teachings that Ed brought us.
00:32:06.148 --> 00:32:18.747
Because as we traverse these challenging times, let's strive to uphold the teachings of Jesus, our shepherd, to guide us away from confusion and towards unity and truth.
00:32:18.747 --> 00:32:27.769
So, until our next Catholic corner, keep questioning what's going on, keep learning and, most importantly, keep your faith.
00:32:27.769 --> 00:32:34.737
Thank you for joining us and God bless you all and, as always, keep fighting the Good Fight.
00:33:05.140 --> 00:33:06.384
Thank you for joining us.
00:33:06.384 --> 00:33:09.781
We hope you enjoyed this theory to action podcast.
00:33:09.781 --> 00:33:18.375
Be sure to check out our show page at team mojoacademycom, where we have everything we discussed in this podcast, as well as other great resources.
00:33:18.375 --> 00:33:22.720
Until next time, keep getting your mojo on.
00:00:01.665 --> 00:00:09.425
00:00:09.425 --> 00:00:17.804
00:00:17.804 --> 00:00:22.222
00:00:51.201 --> 00:01:04.406
00:01:04.406 --> 00:01:08.447
00:01:11.500 --> 00:01:22.692
00:01:22.692 --> 00:01:30.373
00:01:30.373 --> 00:01:40.487
00:01:40.487 --> 00:01:54.070
00:01:54.070 --> 00:02:15.693
00:02:15.693 --> 00:02:30.354
00:02:30.354 --> 00:02:38.463
00:02:38.463 --> 00:02:43.889
00:02:43.889 --> 00:03:01.549
00:03:01.549 --> 00:03:07.609
00:03:07.609 --> 00:03:18.043
00:03:18.082 --> 00:03:31.913
00:03:31.913 --> 00:03:35.568
00:03:35.568 --> 00:03:46.912
00:03:46.912 --> 00:03:57.270
00:03:57.270 --> 00:04:02.715
00:04:02.715 --> 00:04:07.368
00:04:07.368 --> 00:04:12.911
00:04:14.280 --> 00:04:26.029
00:04:26.029 --> 00:04:28.779
00:04:28.779 --> 00:04:36.194
00:04:36.194 --> 00:04:44.586
00:04:44.586 --> 00:04:49.581
00:04:49.581 --> 00:05:00.048
00:05:00.048 --> 00:05:07.132
00:05:07.814 --> 00:05:29.687
00:05:29.687 --> 00:05:34.380
00:05:34.380 --> 00:05:47.430
00:05:47.430 --> 00:05:57.954
00:05:57.954 --> 00:06:05.901
00:06:05.901 --> 00:06:12.596
00:06:12.596 --> 00:06:21.723
00:06:21.723 --> 00:06:32.307
00:06:32.307 --> 00:06:42.194
00:06:44.420 --> 00:06:49.987
00:06:49.987 --> 00:06:54.137
00:06:54.137 --> 00:06:55.839
00:06:55.839 --> 00:07:08.550
00:07:08.550 --> 00:07:13.865
00:07:13.865 --> 00:07:18.901
00:07:18.901 --> 00:07:30.591
00:07:30.591 --> 00:07:31.865
00:07:31.865 --> 00:07:34.725
00:07:34.725 --> 00:07:48.540
00:07:48.540 --> 00:07:55.000
00:07:56.103 --> 00:08:01.798
00:08:01.798 --> 00:08:18.122
00:08:18.122 --> 00:08:28.468
00:08:28.468 --> 00:08:32.081
00:08:32.081 --> 00:08:40.828
00:08:40.828 --> 00:08:53.009
00:08:54.312 --> 00:08:59.866
00:08:59.866 --> 00:09:08.027
00:09:08.027 --> 00:09:24.711
00:09:24.711 --> 00:09:28.418
00:09:28.418 --> 00:09:38.642
00:09:38.642 --> 00:09:40.044
00:09:40.044 --> 00:09:42.089
00:09:42.089 --> 00:09:48.163
00:09:48.403 --> 00:10:09.020
00:10:10.203 --> 00:10:30.941
00:10:32.063 --> 00:10:43.504
00:10:44.524 --> 00:10:57.556
00:10:57.556 --> 00:11:03.136
00:11:03.136 --> 00:11:18.634
00:11:18.634 --> 00:11:36.804
00:11:36.804 --> 00:11:53.618
00:11:53.618 --> 00:12:02.802
00:12:02.802 --> 00:12:03.284
00:12:05.149 --> 00:12:26.831
00:12:26.831 --> 00:12:30.363
00:12:30.363 --> 00:12:36.034
00:12:36.034 --> 00:12:38.038
00:12:38.038 --> 00:12:42.854
00:12:42.854 --> 00:12:57.664
00:12:57.664 --> 00:13:05.136
00:13:05.136 --> 00:13:15.615
00:13:15.615 --> 00:13:29.711
00:13:30.293 --> 00:13:33.566
00:13:33.566 --> 00:13:44.073
00:13:44.073 --> 00:13:50.144
00:13:50.144 --> 00:14:09.976
00:14:09.976 --> 00:14:24.351
00:14:24.351 --> 00:14:37.691
00:14:37.691 --> 00:14:50.697
00:14:50.697 --> 00:15:03.999
00:15:03.999 --> 00:15:14.133
00:15:14.553 --> 00:15:25.817
00:15:25.817 --> 00:15:39.912
00:15:39.912 --> 00:15:40.956
00:15:40.956 --> 00:15:57.764
00:15:57.764 --> 00:16:13.254
00:16:13.254 --> 00:16:34.304
00:16:34.304 --> 00:16:46.991
00:16:46.991 --> 00:16:52.965
00:16:52.965 --> 00:16:54.234
00:16:54.234 --> 00:17:09.048
00:17:10.805 --> 00:17:19.635
00:17:19.635 --> 00:17:32.916
00:17:32.916 --> 00:17:47.912
00:17:47.912 --> 00:17:57.653
00:17:57.653 --> 00:18:03.266
00:18:03.266 --> 00:18:05.773
00:18:05.773 --> 00:18:07.127
00:18:07.127 --> 00:18:20.586
00:18:20.586 --> 00:18:25.035
00:18:25.035 --> 00:18:28.213
00:18:29.025 --> 00:18:44.171
00:18:44.171 --> 00:18:51.994
00:18:51.994 --> 00:19:07.632
00:19:07.632 --> 00:19:14.310
00:19:14.310 --> 00:19:28.576
00:19:28.576 --> 00:19:38.251
00:19:38.251 --> 00:19:51.116
00:19:51.116 --> 00:19:57.210
00:19:57.210 --> 00:20:03.207
00:20:04.424 --> 00:20:15.174
00:20:15.174 --> 00:20:26.214
00:20:26.214 --> 00:20:29.575
00:20:29.575 --> 00:20:34.076
00:20:34.076 --> 00:20:36.090
00:20:36.545 --> 00:20:55.357
00:20:55.357 --> 00:21:05.532
00:21:05.532 --> 00:21:06.635
00:21:06.635 --> 00:21:18.734
00:21:18.734 --> 00:21:25.656
00:21:25.656 --> 00:21:43.538
00:21:43.538 --> 00:21:45.730
00:21:45.730 --> 00:21:51.036
00:21:51.036 --> 00:21:53.067
00:21:55.085 --> 00:22:11.953
00:22:11.953 --> 00:22:30.015
00:22:30.015 --> 00:22:43.538
00:22:43.538 --> 00:22:57.009
00:22:57.009 --> 00:23:13.457
00:23:13.457 --> 00:23:27.547
00:23:27.547 --> 00:23:38.394
00:23:38.394 --> 00:23:39.699
00:23:39.699 --> 00:23:46.480
00:23:48.390 --> 00:24:02.441
00:24:02.441 --> 00:24:20.713
00:24:20.713 --> 00:24:41.462
00:24:41.462 --> 00:24:53.799
00:24:53.799 --> 00:25:00.451
00:25:01.933 --> 00:25:15.036
00:25:15.036 --> 00:25:17.796
00:25:17.796 --> 00:25:20.255
00:25:20.255 --> 00:25:30.049
00:25:30.049 --> 00:25:46.038
00:25:46.038 --> 00:26:03.881
00:26:06.009 --> 00:26:18.559
00:26:18.559 --> 00:26:34.297
00:26:34.297 --> 00:26:50.335
00:26:50.335 --> 00:27:10.400
00:27:10.400 --> 00:27:23.362
00:27:23.362 --> 00:27:33.960
00:27:33.960 --> 00:27:51.920
00:27:53.930 --> 00:28:06.582
00:28:06.582 --> 00:28:12.519
00:28:12.519 --> 00:28:26.433
00:28:26.433 --> 00:28:30.541
00:28:30.541 --> 00:28:51.993
00:28:51.993 --> 00:28:56.260
00:28:56.260 --> 00:29:30.468
00:29:32.361 --> 00:29:51.161
00:29:51.161 --> 00:29:52.964
00:29:52.964 --> 00:29:54.188
00:29:54.188 --> 00:29:57.807
00:29:57.807 --> 00:30:07.744
00:30:07.744 --> 00:30:26.684
00:30:26.684 --> 00:30:33.063
00:30:33.825 --> 00:30:45.444
00:30:45.444 --> 00:30:58.949
00:30:58.949 --> 00:31:05.928
00:31:05.928 --> 00:31:17.701
00:31:19.118 --> 00:31:51.126
00:31:51.126 --> 00:32:06.148
00:32:06.148 --> 00:32:18.747
00:32:18.747 --> 00:32:27.769
00:32:27.769 --> 00:32:34.737
00:33:05.140 --> 00:33:06.384
00:33:06.384 --> 00:33:09.781
00:33:09.781 --> 00:33:18.375
00:33:18.375 --> 00:33:22.720
