MM#488--The Five Year Anniversary of Abbey Gate And The Cost Of Hesitation
FAN MAIL--We would love YOUR feedback--Send us a Text Message
A single moment at Abbey Gate still captures a whole era of American foreign policy: a Marine identifies a threat, asks for permission to act, and is told no until the danger disappears into the crowd. Hours later, the Kabul evacuation turns into a massacre that kills 13 American service members and scores of Afghan civilians. Five years on, we slow down and tell the story with the weight it deserves, because remembrance means more than silence. It means asking what decisions were made, who owned them, and why accountability never showed up afterward.
From there, we zoom out and connect three books that frame the problem in plain terms. We use Michael Mandelbaum’s “The Four Ages of American Foreign Policy” to explain how the United States became a hyperpower and still stumbled through repeated setbacks. We pull in Serhii Plokhy’s writing on the Russo-Ukrainian War to underline a pattern: ambiguity is an invitation, and hesitation is never neutral. When the free world hedges, predators don’t wait politely. We tie those ideas back to Kabul, where America had the tools to secure the evacuation but lacked the competent, decisive leadership to use them.
Then we face the present. Afghanistan under the Taliban is a closed emirate, and the crisis for women and girls is among the worst on the planet. We also dig into Iran and the administration’s next move: “Economic D-Day,” a strategy built around aggressive secondary sanctions and maritime pressure designed to squeeze Iran’s cash without launching another shooting war. The big question is enforcement, especially when most Iranian oil reportedly flows to China and the world watches whether Washington has the stomach to follow through.
Key Points from the Episode:
• Recounting the Abbey Gate timeline and the denied requests to engage a suspected bomber
• Arguing that these deaths are not inevitable but tied to incompetent, unaccountable decisions
• Explaining the “hyperpower without success” idea and why strength fails without will
• Linking Afghanistan, Georgia, and Ukraine through the lesson that ambiguity invites aggression
• Asking what Afghanistan looks like under Taliban rule and what happened to women and girls
• Debating why the US stayed after 2011 and what “finishing the job” would have required
• Assessing Iran pressure after regional strikes and the way allies hedge when costs rise
• Breaking down “Economic D-Day,” secondary sanctions, maritime blockade concepts, and the China enforcement problem
If this episode helped you to see the story more clearly, I'd be grateful if you left a review. Click the link if we've earned five stars from you.
Other goodness
LM#37---American Foreign Policy, part 3
Check us out over at substack! We are building and have built out a whole library of book briefs, just one pager's five-minute read over at the Mojo Book Academy on Substack, mojoacademy.substack.com.
Keep fighting the good fight!
