MM#491--Building a flourishing life when the world changes
FAN MAIL--We would love YOUR feedback--Send us a Text Message A single slogan in giant Gothic letters can tell you exactly what a regime worships. When Father John LaFarge crossed into Nazi Germany in 1938, he saw it blazing over the border: “Ein Volk, Ein Reich, Ein Fuhrer.” We use that moment, and Pope Pius XI’s blunt warning against idolizing “race, the people, and the state,” to ask a question that still feels uncomfortably current: how does a faithful person live when the public world tu...
Key Takeaways
- In his book 'The Pope's Last Crusade', journalist Peter Eisner examines how Jesuit Father John LaFarge and Pope Pius XI resisted the rise of Nazi fascism and totalitarianism through the power of conscience.
- History shows that when public institutions and freedoms collapse, ordinary individuals can still choose resilience by focusing on what they can control, such as their personal faith, health, finances, and character.
- The moving account of a silent, underground Mass in Koblenz illustrates that while citizens may not always be able to stop an oppressive political machine, they can choose to show up and maintain their faith.
- Examining historical parallels—from Nazi Germany and Soviet-era Poland to medieval Spain under the Dhimmi pattern—provides valuable perspective on how to live faithfully and prudently when the world changes.
- Building a flourishing life during times of societal upheaval requires taking a practical inventory of your controllables, including spiritual habits, physical health, durable skills, and strong community relationships.
FAN MAIL--We would love YOUR feedback--Send us a Text Message
A single slogan in giant Gothic letters can tell you exactly what a regime worships. When Father John LaFarge crossed into Nazi Germany in 1938, he saw it blazing over the border: “Ein Volk, Ein Reich, Ein Fuhrer.” We use that moment, and Pope Pius XI’s blunt warning against idolizing “race, the people, and the state,” to ask a question that still feels uncomfortably current: how does a faithful person live when the public world turns hostile to conscience?
We pull key scenes from The Pope’s Last Crusade by journalist Peter Eisner, built from LaFarge’s journals and Vatican archives, including the chilling normalcy of Hitler Youth marches and SS guards on every corner. The story turns intimate in Koblenz, where the Church is pushed underground and a priest arranges a clandestine Mass through a back door, in silence, at real risk. That scene becomes our anchor for Christian resilience, Catholic faith under pressure, and the reality that you cannot always stop the machine, but you can still choose to show up.
From there, we widen the lens to patterns across history: propaganda and intimidation in Germany, underground formation in Poland that shapes the young Karol Wojtyla, quiet courage in France, and a longer analogy in medieval Spain where “protection” never meant equality. Then we bring it home with a practical framework for building a flourishing life by controlling the controllables: prayer and sacraments, sleep and health, financial reserves, durable skills, better attention, stronger relationships, and the hard virtues of restraint, courage, humility, and joy.
Key Points from the Episode:
• Pope Pius XI’s Mit Brennender Sorge and the danger of political idols
• John LaFarge at the German border and the shock of “Ein Volk, Ein Reich, Ein Fuhrer”
• Ordinary Catholics in Koblenz under SS pressure and a silent, locked-door Mass
• How the Nazis targeted Catholic schools, press, youth leagues and used propaganda show trials
• Why courage often comes from a few while many go quietly, with Bonhoeffer as a warning and example
• Poland’s underground culture and seminary life leading to Karol Wojtyla
• France’s fragile “solid ground” and the quiet heroism of villagers hiding refugees
• Medieval Spain and the Dhimmi pattern as a long-term analogy for life under unequal “protection”
• A practical inventory of controllables: faith, health, finances, work, relationships, attention, character, joy
• A weekly action step to build habits now while it costs mainly time
Other goodness
Check us out over at substack! We are building and have built out a whole library of book briefs, just one pager's five-minute read over at the Mojo Book Academy on Substack, mojoacademy.substack.com.
Keep fighting the good fight!
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is the author of 'The Pope's Last Crusade' mentioned in the episode?
The book was written by Peter Eisner, a veteran foreign correspondent for the Washington Post and the Associated Press who built the narrative using Father John LaFarge's journals and newly opened Vatican archives.
What historical event is analyzed to understand living under hostile political regimes?
The episode examines multiple historical examples, primarily focusing on ordinary Catholics navigating Nazi Germany in 1938, underground resistance and seminary life in Poland, and the long-term analogy of medieval Spain.
How can individuals practically prepare for an unpredictable and changing world?
Listeners are encouraged to focus on a practical inventory of controllables, which includes strengthening their faith and sacramental life, maintaining health and sleep, building financial reserves, sharpening durable skills, and cultivating hard virtues.
00:58 - A Warning About Political Idols
02:15 - Entering Hitlerland At The Border
05:59 - Living Faithfully When Freedom Narrows
09:41 - A Silent Mass In Koblenz
15:43 - How Germany Slid Into Fear
17:42 - Poland, France, And Quiet Courage
21:21 - Medieval Spain As A Mirror
24:34 - Control The Controllables Inventory
32:09 - One Concrete Action This Week
34:07 - Prayer, Gratitude, And Closing Charge
A Warning About Political Idols
SPEAKER_00Welcome to the Theory to Action Podcast, where we examine the timeless treasures of wisdom from the great books and less time to help you take action immediately and ultimately to create and lead a flourishing life. Now, here's your host, David Kaiser.
SPEAKER_01Hello, I am David, and welcome back to another Mojo Minute. Whoever exalts race or the people or the state above their standard value and divonizes them to an adulterous level, distorts and perverts an order of the world planned and created by God. That is Pope Pius XI in his encyclical Mit Brennende Zorga with burning concern is the translation. It was smuggled into Nazi Germany and read from every Catholic pulpit in the country on Palm Sunday, nineteen thirty seven. Race, the people, the state. You gotta hold on to those words because in just a minute you're going to see Hitler paint all three of them onto one sign.
Entering Hitlerland At The Border
SPEAKER_01So with that, as usual, let's go to our book of the day. May nineteenth, nineteen thirty eight, the French and German border. Bliben Zie Bita, a Nazi border guard told John Lafarge. Please wait here. The suspicious Nazi official seemed to think that Lafarge could be a Roman Catholic agent because he was dressed as a priest, was an American, and had maps of Italy and Czechoslovakia. Lafarge was led to an empty room where he waited as told. He had boarded the late afternoon train from Paris for the five or six hour journey to the German border. Lafarge was apprehensive along the way and was unable to focus on reading. Central Europe had been experiencing a drought, so the rain that fell may have been an irritation for the sole traveler, with more than he could carry by himself, but the foul weather was a godsend for the parched fields. He spent much of the trip in the dining car where the international cuisine was served with care, and Lafarge relished the unlimited supply of French fries. The train was full when it left Paris, but more and more passengers left the train at each local stop. By the time they reached the German border, only two passengers remained Lafarge and a sad eyed Polish lady in a black dress who said she was transiting Germany for the return home. Lafarge could not avoid the boldly proclaimed glory of the new Germany as the train had pulled into the German border station. One glance out the window was enough, Lafarge wrote in his notes on the trip. Einvolk, Ein Reich, Einfur. One people one Reich one fur greeted you in enormous letters. The Latin alphabet changed abruptly to the German Gothic. Swastikas and Hyles blossomed out as if by magic. We were in Hitler land. I was in Hitler land, along with sixty million Germans. And again, that comes to us from our book of the day, which is The Pope's Last Crusade, how an American Jesuit helped Pope Pius IX, I'm sorry, Pope Pius XI's campaign to stop Hitler. And the author is Peter Eisner. Eisner is a veteran foreign correspondent for the Washington Post and the Associated Press. He built this book from Lafarge's own journals and newly opened Vatican Archives. Now, Father John Lafarge was an American Jesuit editor. Just weeks after this scene, Pius XI secretly asked him to write an encyclical condemning Nazi racism and anti-Semitism. So picture that platform out the window in the enormous German Gothic letters Einvolk Einreich Einfuhr One people, one Reich, one leader. There it is. Race, the people, the state, all raised up to an idol. Fourteen months after the Pope warned against it, sixty million Germans woke up under that sign every morning. So how? This is our question. So how did a faithful Catholic or Christian family live under that system? And
Living Faithfully When Freedom Narrows
SPEAKER_01our most recent election, which received much attention, and as it should have, but elections have consequences, we know that. And the purpose of this podcast has never simply been to follow elections, it's also to help us build a flourishing life. Now, granted, we would love a flourishing life if it was built on freedom, true freedom, and liberty. But as we know, it appears our freedoms and our liberties are going to be curtailed, or at least narrowed, because we have a radical wing of the Democratic Party that's taking over. So then that begs the question: how do we stay faithful? How do we stay thoughtful, resourceful, and useful to the people around us? How do we live lives that are building to a flourishing life? So we're going to explore that through history and the great books with preparation and certainly not without, not without, not with panic. That only exacerbates the situation. So with that all said, we know that things can change quickly. We all know, especially here in Ohio, the spring of 2020. The stay at home order that was announced on Sunday, March 22nd, which took effect at 1159 that Monday night. So in about a day and a half, how we worked, how we gathered, how we even went to mass to celebrate our Lord and our God, it all changed. The COVID mandates came fast and furious. And most people were not prepared. I know I wasn't. And I really don't think most in modern America could believe that they could shut down our country with just an authoritarian bent like they did. That was probably the precursor to something else. Again, not to have us panic, but that should give us all pause. So how we judge laws, we can't be in the rumor mill, but we should ask what will make our households stronger, even if our worst fears never happen. Our main takeaway should be we have to prepare for the worst and pray for the best. And I think the best way to do that is to look back through history and see how people had gotten through the past, how people live faithfully through upheavals. We're certainly not the only country that has gone through these types of things. Hopefully, it will just be a little speed bump along the way to more freedom, more liberty, and an ordered civilization. But you never know. We have a fragile country, we have a polarized country. So, and if the government happens to turn oppressive, what are we going to do about it? Now history won't hand us a prediction, but it does show us how real households and churches tried to make the best choices. And I have we have from our book the example of Germany, the everyday Catholic in 1938, and Lafarge going through that border station and traveling on to Koblenz on the Rhine. So let's pick up the book again, because we'll get right, we'll get the the words straight from Lafarge's journal.
A Silent Mass In Koblenz
SPEAKER_01Go on to the book. Lafarge looked down on the city from the heights of the Erin Brettenstein, where he could view the series of fortresses that had gardened the Rhine region for a millennium. Koblenz, the 2,000-year-old city at the confluence of the Rhine and Moselle rivers, was a focal point of Hitler's hatred of the Western powers after the European Armistice of 1918. The city had been headquartered for the Interallied Rhineland High Commission, which was created by the victorious Allies after the Great War, be World War I. Germany as the vanquished nation had been monitored for more than a decade from the headquarter offices here. Lafarge looked down and saw marches of Hitler Youth. Again, we're back in 1938. Lafarge saw marches of Hitler youth, SS soldiers on guard at every corner. He saw the effects of Nazism summed up by Shardin's fatalistic lament. Quote, we're all going to be in Dachau sooner or later. So what's the use of bothering? Dachau was the first German concentration camp and had served as a detention center for mostly political prisoners since 1938. Shardin shared the same fear, Schardin is his priest friend that he came to visit on his way to Rome. Shardin shared the same fear felt in Rome and throughout much of Europe. He and other clerics in Germany faced intensifying attacks. They were being driven underground one by one. Lafarge wondered whether Catholicism could even survive the onslaught of Nazism. Shardin could hardly leave his church. He asked Lafarge to celebrate a clandestine mass at the chapel of the Franciscan Brothers of the Sick and Koblenz. The Franciscans have been targeted the previous year in an extension of Nazi persecution of the Catholic Church that stepped up after the Pope issued his anti-Nazi encyclical the year before. One hundred and seventy five members, I'm sorry, one hundred and seventy members of the order had been arrested on trumped up charges of quote corrupting the people. The government had already shuttered the chapel, and the diocese was largely doing its work in secret, whether it was running a recreation program and a ramshackled building that was frankly too dingy for the Nazis to bother appropriating, or at the chapel itself. That Saturday Shardin gave Lafarge the massive key with which I was to let myself in the back door, Lafarge said. I was to speak to nobody, merely celebrate mass and then depart. They came to Mass, he said, in order to pray for liberation from Hitler. The following morning, therefore, I unlocked the sacristy store, the sacristy door, and I found the altar boy waiting. I went out onto the altar and found the chapel filled with a silent congregation. Not a sound was uttered except the murmured responses of the server. I never felt so close to any congregation in my life. Everyone present received communion. When the mass was completed, the farge left silently, went through the back out, back out onto the street, and locked the door. He returned to the parish house and said goodbye to Shardin, and he headed back to the train station, where he purchased a ticket for his next destination, Prague. He would discover over the weekend that Czechoslovakia and Germany were on the brink of war. And again, that comes to us from the Pope's Last Crusade, how an American Jesuit helped Pope Pius XI's campaign to stop Hitler by Peter Eisner. So as we go back to the book, what a powerful scene we we get here. Just to look at what ordinary Catholic and Koblenz saw. They saw Hitler youth marching through the streets. They saw the SS men on guard at every corner. They saw a parish priest who could hardly leave his own church. They saw a chapel that was shut down by the government. And 170 members of one religious order were arrested and never to be seen again. And then you listen to that priest friends lament. We're all going to be in Dachau sooner or later. So what's the use of bothering? And Dachau had held political prisoners since 1933. This was 1938. And notice that. the camps started with political prisoners. That is revealing in and of itself. And then watch what happens. The same priest who said, What's the use? hands the Farge a massive key. Tells him, Speak to nobody, let yourself in the back door, say mass and leave. The Farge walks out to the altar and the chapel is full. Incredibly, not a sound is heard by a full congregation. But just the murmured responses of one altar boy. You see, the answer to what's the use is the key, the back door in the Mass. Those Catholics could not stop the SS or the war that was coming. But they could still show up. They could pray and receive our Lord together, knowing that they had been caught cold, knowing that they have knowing that having been caught could cost them their lives.
How Germany Slid Into Fear
SPEAKER_01So how did it all come in five years? From nineteen thirty-eight to nineteen thirty-three? How did all this happen? How did we even get here if you were a Catholic or a Christian in 1938 Germany in Koblenz? Well, we covered in Mojo Minute 486 that Hitler got the center Catholic Party's votes for the Enabling Act in 1933. And then the Nazis turned around and wiped out the Catholic schools, the press, and the youth leagues. So when Pope Pius XI fought back in 1937, the Nazis answered with their show trials, their smear campaign. And then the bishops answered with numbers. Of the 25,000 priests in Germany, only 22 had been convicted. That wasn't justice, that was propaganda dressed up as a courtroom, and facts no longer matter to the Nazis. So then Germany had heroes like the Lutheran pastor at the time, Dietrich Bonhoeff, who would be executed in 1945. It only had complicity because too many Christians failed to defend the Jews. So what helps a man act when the bishops and the cardinals go silent? Bon offer helps us, as a Lutheran, to know what to do. History will tell us that most will go quietly in the face of adversity, and only the few will be heroic. So that's Germany in 1938.
Poland, France, And Quiet Courage
SPEAKER_01So let's turn to a very Catholic country. Poland. Remember the sad-eyed Polish widow on Lafarge's train. Just sixteen months later, Germany would invade her country. On November 6, 1939, the Germans called the professors of Krakow's Jagalonian University to a lecture. It was a trap. The Gestapo arrested about 180 of them. They shipped them off to the concentration camps, too. One lecture. One trap. Tells of the young Jagalonian student by the name of Kerwatiwa, who broke rocks in a quarry day by day, who kept the Polish culture alive in his heart and in a secret theater by night, and by 1942 had joined the underground seminary. So now we have a secret mass in Koblenz, and we have a secret seminary in Krakow. When the institutions were shut down, the altar in the family carried what the universities could not, what the institutions would not. That young seminarian would become Pope John Paul II, Saint Pope John Paul II. So our third example, because we've had Germany in 1938, Poland in 1939, is France. When the solid ground of the daughter of the Church gives way. That's what France is known for. The daughter of the Catholic Church. So Lafarge boarded his train in Paris in a country that had to feel like solid as rock. Now we had just passed Veterans Day this past week, on November 11, 1918. Over a hundred years ago, Germany signed that armistice ending World War I in that railway car at Campion. On June 22nd, 1940, Hitler made France sign her surrender in that very car. That very railroad railway car. So two years after Lafarge's comfortable dinner with that unlimited supply of French fries, always good for any American, amen. Paris was under that swastika. A nation that thought it was on solid ground found how fragile that ground really can be. And then in a little Protestant village of Langebon Sir Le Gaon, ordinary farmers and teachers and housewives hid thousands of refugees, many of them Jewish children. And they didn't have any army. They had no plan to on how to save France. They just decided whom to trust and whom to help by themselves. So then we come to our final analogy and probably our best analogy.
Medieval Spain As A Mirror
SPEAKER_01Because the more I thought about all this, the more I thought think that medieval Spain could be our best analogy. Because Spain was not peacefully handed over in 7 Eleven. The Muslim armies invaded and defeated Christian ruler after Christian ruler. They imposed treaties at sword point. The Treaty of Tumur in 713 chose the bargain. Christians were able to keep their lives and their churches and their faith, but they owed submission and a yearly tribute. That was the Domini status. It's a protection without equality. Christians pay a special tax. They could not build new churches and they could not share the gospel with Muslims. And frankly, too often, as we know, women and children were taken as slaves. Certainly it broke the treaty. But no matter to the Muslims. And converting to Islam removed the tax and sometimes opened doors, but the sword established the Muslim role and the economic pressure spread its faith. So by 1854, a Christian writer in Cordoba, Spain, named Paul Alvarez, warned that young Christians loved Arabic literature. While neglecting their Latin and Christian learning. You see, the conqueror's culture was displacing the Christian people's inheritance. Certainly some resisted. Paleo's victory at Corvadaga around 722 became a symbol of surviving Christian foothold. And then in Cordoba in the eight fifties, forty-eight Christians they were executed, revealing the deadly limits of that so-called protection. Now certainly some endured, I'm not meaning to say they didn't. The Mozarabs they kept an ancient mace or the ancient mass alive through generations of Muslim rule. And they're their right. Their mass right survives in Toledo today, but permission to practice was never equality. And to surrender at a sword point was never consent. So we're going to come back to this period with more great books the more I study Spain and the Muslim invasion. Because again, I do think it gives us our best uh our best analogy. But our our final point is in a country that we really can't control, we can take responsibility for how we act as the faithful.
Control The Controllables Inventory
SPEAKER_01We can control some choices, we can control some and influence some outcomes, And we can only prepare on how we treat others. Certainly the Catholics of Koblenz couldn't control Berlin, at least not by thir nineteen thirty-eight. But they could choose every Sunday whether to show up. So as we go through a practical inventory, let's remind ourselves of the important things, the permanent things. Certainly our faith, prayer, mass, the sacraments, scripture, service, certainly our health. Still gotta daily move, gotta get good sleep, make good food choices, me included, gotta take preventative care. Our finances. You gotta know your essential expenses, gotta cut the avoidable obligations, gotta build reserves. We gotta do our work well. Gotta sharpen our useful skills. Can't certainly depend on a single employer or platform. Remember when YouTube canceled me. So we have to do our work well, so well that we become a vital employee doesn't mean that we absolutely prevent ourselves from any repercussions of an aggressive state or an aggressive employer with different views than ourselves, but we got to put ourselves in the best situation. And then we get to family and friends. We should give more time, share more meals, and try to pass on our faith. We can always read the good books in our downtime. At this point, we should probably be building a physical library because digital books can be erased by an authoritarian government. And then attention certainly can't stick our head in the sand like an ostrich. But boy, let me tell you, living on Twitter is like sitting in a bar full of drunks yelling about nothing in particular. It's vile. I don't recommend it. And in the very end, our character is what will be a permanent thing. All the virtues, our honesty, our courage, our patience, our restraint, especially towards those people we oppose. And boy, there's a lot of them, Arthur. And our humility, which is sometimes the hardest virtue to attain, certainly is for me. I've had to come to terms with some of all this myself this past week, past two weeks. And boy, humility. It is a tough thing to acquire. And in the very end, as the Christian, as the Catholic, it's joy. We are a joyful people. Joy in the face of adversity. Joy in God's beauty and God's creation. Take joy in sports. Take joy in good music. Take joy in playing with your kids and gratitude for your family. Take joy in smiling even when it's hard to smile. And sometimes lately it has been hard to smile. And that attention ties back to one of our best book briefs, Cal Newport's Deep Work. You know, Cal taught us that focus is a skill. And twelve hours of cable news a week will only make you more anxious and less useful. So let's ditch it. We're not going to skip the faith line. And Coblenz, we learned. When everything else had been taken, the Mass or Church was what was left. Let's build that habit now while we can. It's going to cost us nothing but time, but certainly time well spent. And here comes our most important nugget. The question is not only what kind of country will we live in, it's also what kind of people we will become. Because time is marching on. And how will we help others to live well, to build a flourishing life for ourselves and for our friends and neighbors and our family? You know, the Catholics in Koblenz, that Koblenz Chapel, they didn't get to choose their country. That the country was really chosen for them. By 1933, it was well on its way. By 1938, that ship has sailed. You know, the environment had changed drastically. We're trying to prevent that in our country. But we might get to a point where it's 1938 in America. The environment will have changed. It's like saying you want to go outside and have the environment be 80 degrees. It's December in Ohio. It's not going to be 80 degrees. There's no reason that's delusional to think that you're going to walk out in Ohio in December and have it be 80 degrees. If it is, the second coming is probably going to happen. Most times, the average temperature is much less than 80 degrees. So it's delusional to think that we're going to achieve that. So then you have to work within the environment. That's what we're trying to talk about today. You know, Hitler had made the choices. Those enormous letters at the border. Those choices were made by 1938. Now, every one of them could choose what kind of people they were going to be that Sunday morning. That's what we want to emphasize. Let's start controlling the controllables. The Lutheran Bonhoeffer said nearly the same thing from a cell in a great book. The real question for the responsible man is how the coming generation is going to live. That's what we're trying to convey. And here's the hard truth. For the next two years or the next two decades, or frankly, for even the rest of our lives, our liberty may be curtailed and our freedoms diminished. But saints have been made in such times, and we should not think any different. Bonhoeffer had his cell. He was executed in 1945. Carol Watiwa survived. He went to the underground seminary, and thankfully he survived. He went on to become a great saint. The Mozarab families in Toledo, that silent congregation in Koblenz, not one of them chose their times, but every one of them chose what to do with the time that was given them.
One Concrete Action This Week
SPEAKER_01So here's, as we wrap up this mojo minute, here's the one action we want to take this week. Pick your weakest area in that inventory that I had given and do one concrete thing about it before next Sunday. If you've let your Mass slip, you got to start there. Let's get back to Mass. If you're just a Christian, let's get back to church. You know, those Catholics and Coblenz, they slip through the back door to avoid the SS. All you and I have to do is drive across town. So, and right now nobody's asking us where our going, where we're going, what our papers are. And with Veterans Day just behind us, let's say a prayer for the men and women who stood in the gap for our liberty downrange. Because of them, you and I so far have never had to sign anything in a railway car or slip into mass through a locked back door. So let's be thankful for that. And again, let's control the controllables in our life. It will reduce our stress. And that's where we're going to be taking our podcast in the future. For the next year and a half, we're going to be going into history. How can we build a flourishing life through learning from history? We're going to be going into the great books. How do we build good habits? How do we go deeper into our faith and into our culture of Western civilization? What a resource we have. And then we're going to dive back into that daily habitual work that we got to do each and every day of building a flourishing life. So until next time, as always, keep getting your mojo on. And most importantly, keep fighting the good fight.
Prayer, Gratitude, And Closing Charge
SPEAKER_00Thank you for joining us. We hope you enjoyed this theory to action podcast. Be sure to check out our show page at TeamMojoAcademy.com, where we have everything we discussed in this podcast, as well as other great resources. Until next time, getting your mojo.